“Corruptocracy” Harms High Performing Faculty in Engineering Education
AUTHORS
Thanikachalam Vedhathiri,Former Professor and HOD, Center for International Affairs, National Institute of Technical Teachers Training and Research, Chennai, India
ABSTRACT
Higher education growth is based on supporting the high-performing faculty teams. If they are denied resources, funds, and autonomy, they can't contribute to the knowledge capital. In the last 25 years, many corrupt Chief Executive Officers of higher education in India have been suspended and the cases were filed in various courts. The CEOs got the posts due to a weak selection process. Based on this research, a theory on "Corruptocracy" has been synthesized which describes the corrupt and unethical administration by the corrupt CEOs who institutionalized the corrupt practices. Many of the high achieving faculty members are not able to contribute to the knowledge capital and move up in their career ladder due to "Corruptocracy". This is due to poor governance. The research is based on the data collected from 540 faculty members over 50 years using a naturalistic evaluation model. The research results provided important findings on the performance of the higher education institutes like slow growth, the suffering of outstanding faculty members, negligible contribution to knowledge capital due to not developing new programs & projects, and not focusing on the human and knowledge capital. The CEOs control the development of human and knowledge capital and give the highest priority to self and coterie development. The unethical administration has to be checked scrupulously through the conduct and institutional governance rules. The Board has to get six-monthly feedback from the faculty members and correct the deviations which will accelerate the output of quality knowledge and human capital. Considering the need for an outstanding CEO, further research is recommended.
KEYWORDS
Corruptocracy, Poor governance, Loss to the high-performing faculty members, Loss of knowledge, Human capital development, Academic audit, Performance audit
REFERENCES
[1] Aishalabi “Corruption in higher education appears to be on the rise globally,” (2013), https://www.chronicle.com/article/corruption-in-higher-education-appears-to-be-on-the-rise-globally-report-says/
[2] A. Kamp, “Engineering education in a rapidly changing world,” Tu Delft University, Center for Education, (2016)
[3] A. Pajazite and S. Gerguri, “Towards university ethics and academic excellence: Addressing and fighting corruptions,”
[4] A. Lonsotale, “Corruption in higher education,” https://integrityaction.org
[5] A. L. Osipian, “Corruption in higher education: Does it differ across the nation and why?” ERIC, Research in Comparative and International Education, vol.3, no.4, pp:345-365, (2008), https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ891953
[6] A. L. Osipian, “Higher education corruption in world media: Prevalence, patterns, and forms, (2013)
[7] A. Kizalic, “Corruption in higher education fiction or reality,” Inter Logos Central University ITC, (2015)
[8] H. Bathelt and R. Gibson, “Learning in organized anarchies: The nature of technological search processes at trade fairs,” Regional Studies, vol.49, pp.985-1002, (2015)
[9] Creating a Cycle of Incompetence, EDC, pp.16-17, (2012)
[10] D. Beanland and R. Hadgraft, “Engineering education: Transformation and innovation,” Malborne-Victoria: RMIT University Press, (2013)
[11] Davidson, “Facing up to the c-word corruption in higher education,” theconversation.com/facing-up to-the-c-word-corruption-in-higher-education-23854, (2005)
[12] V. Deepa, “Higher education in India is at risk,” (2018)
[13] D. G. Faust, “The role of the university in a changing world,” Boston: Harvard University, (2010)
[14] A. Easton, “Decision making: A short course for professionals,” vol.1, New York, John Wiley
[15] G. Mohamedbhai, “Higher education: A hotbed of corruption,” (2015) http//www.insidehighered.com/blogs/world-view/higher-education-hotbed-corruption
[16] G. Mohamedbhai, “Fraud and corruption in higher education; why, how and what role for leadership,” Accra, Ghana, International Conference Leadership for a Changing Public-Private Higher Education Funding Landscape, pp.18-20, October, (2017)
[17] G. J. Daviss, G. E. Kirk, and D. A. Nethercot, “Educating engineers for the 21st Century,” London: Royal Academy of Engineering, (2007)
[18] E. G. Guba and Y. S. Lincoln, “Fourth Generation of Evaluation,” Newbury Park, Sage
[19] J. Washburn, “University, inc.: The corporate corruption of higher education,” Reed Business Information, A Division of Reed Elsevier Inc, (2006)
[20] J. Hallak and M. Poisson, “Corrupt schools, corrupt universities: What can be done?” Paris: UNESCO: International Institute for Educational Planning, (2007)
[21] J. Attich, “The manifestation of corruption in higher education: The role of the university administration, (2015)
[22] K. Ren, “Fighting against academic corruption: A critique of recent policy development in China,” Higher Education Policy, vol.25, no.1, pp.19-38, (2012), https://link.springer.com/article/10.1057/hep.2011.20
[23] K. L. Ochse, “Preventing corruption in the education system,” Division 42 Sector Project: Developing and Testing of Strategies and Instruments for Prevention of Corruption in the Education System, GTZ, Germany, (2004)
[24] P. Kennedy, “How to combine research options. Practical triangulation,” (2009)
[25] K. Rostiashvili, “Corruption in the higher education system of Georgia,” Transnational Crime and Corruption Center (TRACCC), (2004)
[26] J. Kusum and S. Kusum, “Corruption: it’s silent penetration into the Indian education system,” Journal of Education and Practice, vol.4, no.1, pp.30-35, (2013)
[27] N. R. F. Mailer, “Problem-solving discussions and conferences: Leadership, methods, and skills,” New York, Me Graw-Hill
[28] M. Weber, “Bureaucracy,” Retrieved from https://www.toppr.com/guides/fundamentals-of-economics-and-management/evolution-of-management-thought/bureaucratic-theory-by-max-weber/
[29] D. McFarland and C. Gomez, “4 organizational analysis,” (2013), Coursera. pp.60-77, https://www.dropbox.com/s/78ktuqc11mcc4kz/Organizational_Analysis_Book_2016.pdf?dl=0
[30] Measures to Prevent Corruption, www.toolkit.inceenite/TNEEcms/updates/1038/Preventing_Corruption_in_The_Education_System.pdf
[31] J. Martin, “A garbage can model of the psychological research process,” American Behavioral Scientist, vol.25, pp.131-151, DOI: 10.1177/0002766428102500203
[32] M. Weber, “German Politics,” London: Faber and Faber Ltd, pp.128
[33] M. Bassis, “A primer on the transformation of higher education in America,” National Institute of Learning Outcome Assessment, (2015)
[34] M. D. Cohen, J. G. March, and J. P. Olsen, “A garbage can model of organizational choice,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.17. no.1, pp.1-25, DOI:10.2307/2392088
[35] J. Olsen, “The origins of the gargage can model,” (2011), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=raTM7OSSQ8k
[36] R. Mukherjee, “Indian education system: What needs to change?” UN Pleaders, (2007)
[37] R. Graham, “The global state of the art in engineering education,” New Engineering Education, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston, (2018)
[38] R. H. Hall, “The concept of bureaucracy: An empirical assessment,” The American Journal of Sociology, vol.69, no.1, pp.33
[39] S. Coughian, “Corruption and bribery in the classroom,” (2013)
[40] S. Neelakantan, “Fighting corruption at India’s universities,” Public Radio International (PRI), (2010)
[41] M. Smirnova, “Country report on corruption in higher education and research in the Russian higher education,” (2013)
[42] J. Steen, J. A. Ford, and M. Verrey, “Symbols, sublimes, solutions, and problems: A garbage can model of megaprojects,” Project Management Journal, vol.48, pp.117-131, (2017)
[43] S. P. Heyneman, K. H. Anderson, and N. Nuraliyeva, “The cost of corruption in higher education,” Rent-seeking, Public Sector-Higher Education. Comparative Education Review
[44] V. Thanikachalam, “Enhancing institutional governance beyond the society’s act of 1860. (Steps to Improve Autonomous Institutes’ Administration through Board of Governance),” Journal Engineering of Education Transformations, Special Issue, (2016)
[45] V. Thanikachalam, “Building institute’s culture and values to facilitate excellent high performing institute, Journal of Engineering and Technology Education, vol.10, no.1, pp-18-22, (2016)
[46] V. Thanikachalam, “Performance management and turnaround mechanism of poorly performing institutes,” Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, Journal of Engineering Education Transformations, vol.32, no.2, pp-46-54, (2018)
[47] V. Thanikachalam, “Institutional transformation and development in engineering education to meet volatility, complexity, and ambiguity (VUCA),” 5th International Conference on Transformations in Engineering Education, Theagarajar College of Engineering, Madurai, Tamil Nadu, India, (2018)
[48] V. Thanikachalam, “Educational management ecosystem for facilitating the development of professional competencies of CEOs in higher education,” 5th International Conference on Transformations of Engineering Education, Thegarajar College of Engineering, Madurai, India, (2018)
[49] V. Thanikachalam, “Academic excellence through an improved ecosystem and faculty engagement,” 5th International Conference on Transformations on Engineering Education, Theagarajar College of Engineering, Madurai, India, (2018)
[50] V. Thanikachalam, “Strategies for eliminating corruption in engineering education and fostering excellence in human capital development,” 5th International Conference on Transformations in Engineering Education, Theagarajar College of Engineering, Madurai, India, (2018)
[51] V. Thanikachalam, “Enhancing interdisciplinary research in engineering education (IDREE),” 5TH International Conference on Transformations on Engineering Education, Theagarajar College of Engineering, Madurai, India, (2018)
[52] V. Thanikachalam, “Desired educational ecosystem in the fast-growing educational institutes in India,” AP-International Conference on Transformations in Engineering Education, SRM University, Amaravati, AP, India, (2018)
[53] V. Thanikachalam, “Advanced educational system to undertake international consultancy projects in the engineering institutes under global economy,” AP-International Conference on Transformations in Engineering Education, SRM University, Amaravati, AP, India, (2018)
[54] V. Thanikachalam, “Dynamic process for enhancing engineering faculty competence in India,” AP-International Conference on Transformations in Engineering Education, SRM University, Amaravati, AP, India, (2018)
[55] Transparency International, Corruption by topic- Education, https://www.transparency.org/en/
[56] Triangulation-Better Evaluation, (2018), Retrieved from https://www.betterevaluation.org/en/evaluation-options/triangulation
[57] UNDP, (2011), Fighting Corruption in the Education Sector, Methods, Tools, and Good Practices, Bureau for Development Policy, One United Nations Plaza, New York. https://www.undp.org/publications/fighting-corruption-education-sector
[58] United States Institute of Peace, (2010), Governance, Corruption, and Conflict – A Study Guide Series on Peace and Conflict for Independent Learners and Classroom Instructors, United States Institute of Peace, Washington, D.C, USA
[59] V. Valentino, “Managing corruption in Moldova, thesis: Master of public administration in international development at the Kennedy school of government (KSG), Harvard University
[60] W. Kigotho, “Corruption is eroding higher education’s benefits,” University World News, Issue 290, (2013), www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?-201310060
[61] W. K. Hoy and C. G. Miskel, “Educational administration, theory, research, and practice,” ADO, Sixth Edition, Boston, Massachusetts
[62] W. J. Kresse, “International corruption in higher education: Analysis of causes and reforms at the second-largest institution of higher education,” Files eric.ed.gov/full text/EJ1139512, Spring 2017, Issue-1, pp.35-40
[63] G. W. Tierney and N. S. Sabharwal, “Academic corruption: Culture and trust in Indian higher education,” International Journal of Educational Development, vol.55, pp.30-40, July, (2017), DOI:10.1016/j.jedudev.2017.05.003
[64] World Bank (2014) Future Development, Six Strategies to Fight Corruption, blogs
[65] World University News, Corruption is Eroding Higher Education’s Benefits, https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20131001160142405
[66] Y. Zhu and A. Kindarto, “A garbage can model of government IT project failures in developing countries: The effects of leadership, decision structures, and team competence,” Government Information Quarterly, vol.33, pp.629-637, (2016)