Teacher's Organizational Commitment in Mechanistic School Structures: A Study Conducted on the Job Characteristics of a Private School in Abu Dhabi

AUTHORS

Hadi Fouad Masnour,The British University in Dubai, UAE
Solomon Arulraj David*,The British University in Dubai, UAE

ABSTRACT

Organizational structures are fundamental requirements of schools; the structure determines the components of the organization, which in turn contribute to the formation of job characteristics. Job characteristics affect labor motivation and satisfaction while feeding into the organizational commitment of the staff. The study investigates the effect of mechanistic structures on job characteristics and their combined impact on job satisfaction and organizational commitment. The Job Diagnostic Survey (JDS) and Motivational Potential Score (MPS) investigate the perceptions of an international school's teaching staff in Abu Dubai, United Arab Emirates (UAE). The findings indicate teachers possess affective commitment towards the school yet perceive their roles as severely curtailed in terms of authority and autonomy and limited in their ability to utilize diverse skill sets due to the extreme specialization inherent in their roles. Teachers view the organization as highly centralized due to the bureaucracy with high degrees of specialization and formalization. Still, they are motivated due to their perception of the importance of their roles. The number of cases is the limitation of the study, although it helped to focus on depth. Future studies may consider more cases for a broader understanding.

 

KEYWORDS

Organizational commitment, Job satisfaction, Job characteristics, Motivation, Mechanistic structure, Specialization, Formalization, Centralization

REFERENCES

[1]     K. A. Abu Afifeh, and S. A. David, “Identifying leadership styles that influence students’ learning environment: Perspectives from five schools in Abu Dhabi,” UAE, Research Demagogue, vol.3, no.1, pp.40-45, (2016)
[2]     P. Adler and B. Borys, “Two types of bureaucracy: Enabling and coercive,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.41, no.1, pp.61-89
[3]     G. Ahmady, M. Mehrpour, and A. Nikooravesh, “Organizational Structure,” Procedia - Social and Behavioural Sciences, vol.230, pp.455-462, (2016)
[4]     W. Albasha and S. A. David, “Teacher’s perspectives on engaged teaching: Study from an American curriculum school in Dubai, Specialty Journal of Knowledge Management, vol.4, no.2, pp.1-13, (2019)
[5]     R. Al Hassanieh and S. A. David, ‘The influence of distributed leadership on effective school governance and improved school performance: A study conducted in two private schools in the UAE,” vol.7, no.1, (2020)
[6]     A. Al Husseini and David, “The impact of head teachers’ instructional leadership role on teachers’ professional practices in four private schools in Dubai,” the UAE, Research Nebula, vol.6, no.1, pp.23-28, (2017)
[7]     H. Al Samkari and S. A. David, “The role and impacts of authentic leadership on staff engagement and performance: A study among school leaders and teachers in private schools in the UAE,” Specialty Journal of Psychology and Management, vol.5, no.4, pp.65-78, (2019)
[8]     H. Angle, J. Perry, “Organisational commitment: Individual and organizational influences,” Work and Occupations, vol.10, no.2, pp.123-146
[9]     O. Arogundade, A. Arogundade, and O. Oyebanji, “Influence of perceived organizational justice on teachers’ commitment in selected secondary schools in Lagos State, Nigeria,” Journal of Scientific Research and Reports, vol.4, no.7, pp.605-613, (2015)
[10]  S. Aryee, Y. Chay, and J. Chew, “An investigation of the predictors and outcomes of career commitment in three career stages,” Journal of Vocational Behaviour, vol.44, pp.1-16
[11]  S. Baroudi and S. A. David, “Nurturing female leadership skills through peer mentoring role: A study among undergraduate students in the United Arab Emirates,” Higher Education Quarterly, vol.74, no.4, pp.458-474, (2020), https://doi.org/10.1111/hequ.12249(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[12]  S. Bashaireh and S. A. David, “Appreciate leadership and teacher’s subjective well-being: An appreciative tool for an appreciative outcome,” Specialty Journal of Psychology and Management, vol.5, no.3, pp.46-63, (2019)
[13]  K. Beard, “An exploratory study of academic optimism and flow of elementary school teachers,” Electronic Thesis or Dissertation, (2008), Retrieved from https://etd.ohiolink.edu
[14]  K. Beard, W. Hoy, and A. Woolfolk Hoy, “Academic optimism of individual teachers: Confirming a new construct,” Teaching and Teacher Education, vol.26, no.5, pp.1136-1144, (2010)
[15]  E. Bell and A. Bryman, “The ethics of management research: An exploratory content analysis,” British Journal of Management, vol.18, no.1, pp.63-77, (2011)
[16]  D. A. Bernstein and P. W. Nash, “Essentials of psychology (4th ed.),” Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company, (2008)
[17]  J. W. Berry, “Immigration, acculturation and adaptation,” Applied Psychology, vol.46, pp.5-68
[18]  M. Blood and C. Hulin, “Alienation, environmental characteristics, and worker responses,” Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.51, no.3, pp.284-290
[19]  N. Bruning and R. Snyder, “Sex and position as predictors of organizational commitment,” Academy of Management Journal, vol.26, no.3, pp.485-491
[20]  T. Bucic and S. Gudergan, “The impact of organizational settings on creativity and learning in alliances,” I, vol.7, no.3, pp.257-273, (2004)
[21]  M. Buys, C. Olckers, and P. Schaap, ‘The construct validity of the revised job diagnostic survey,” South African Journal of Business Management, vol,38, no.2, pp.33-40, (2007)
[22]  Y. Cheng, “The relationships of job attitudes and organizational commitment to different aspects of organizational environment,” ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 318 779
[23]  A. Cohen, “Multiple commitments in the workplace: An integrative approach,” Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, (2003)
[24]  J. Creswell, “Research design: Qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods approach,” (2nd ed.), Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, (2003)
[25]  H. A. R. Daraghmeh and S. A. David, “Benchmarking of educational leaders’ technology utilization: A study of the attitudes of education leaders in using technology in the UAE,” Education Research Journal, vol.7, no.3, pp.48-58, (2017)
[26]  S. A. David et.al, “An exploration into student learning mobility in higher education among the Arabian gulf cooperation council countries,” International Journal of Educational Development, vol.55, pp.41-48, (2017)
[27]  S. A. David, “Internationalization of higher education in the UAE and the implications for undergraduate student’s institutional choice for postgraduate studies,” Transitions: Journal of Transient Migration, vol.1, no.2, pp.235-250, (2017)
[28]  S. A. David, “Knowledge convergence towards economic polarization: Undergraduate students’ postgraduate course choice in the UAE,” International Journal of Knowledge Management Studies, vol.8, no.3-4, pp.316-328, (2017)
[29]  S. A. David and A. Abukari, “Perspectives of teachers on the selection and the development of the school leaders in the United Arab Emirates,” International Journal of Educational Management, (2019), https://doi.org/10.1108/IJEM-02-2019-0057(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[30]  G. Dreher, “Individual needs as correlates of satisfaction,” Journal of Vocational Behaviour, vol.17, no.1, pp.89-94, (1980)
[31]  S. El Alfy and S. A. David, “Investigating organizational justice in higher education in U.A.E,” International Journal of Management in Education, vol.11, no.2, pp.163-187, (2017)
[32]  D. Farrell and C. Rusbult, “Exchange variables as predictors of job satisfaction, job commitment, and turnover: The impact of rewards, costs, alternatives, and investments,” Organisational Behaviour and Human Performance, vol.27-28, pp.78-95
[33]  B. Fidler, “School leadership: Some key ideas,” School Leadership and Management, vol.17, no.1, pp.23-38
[34]  M. Grosof and H. Sardy, “A research primer for the social and behavioral sciences,” Journal of Marketing Research, vol.24, no.1, pp.131
[35]  J. Hackman and E. Lawler, “Employee reaction to job characteristics, Journal of Applied Psychology Monograph, vol.55, no.3, pp.259-286
[36]  J. Hackman and G. Oldham, “Development of the job diagnostic survey,” Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.60, no.21, pp.159-170
[37]  J. Hage and R. Dewar, “Elite values versus organizational structure in predicting innovation,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.18, no.3, pp.279-289
[38]  E. Hall, “Nonverbal communication for educators,” Theory into Practice, vol.26, no.1, pp.364-367
[39]  J. D. Handyside, “Satisfactions and aspirations,” Occupational Psychology, vol.35, no.4, pp.213–244
[40]  M. J. Hatch, “Organization theory: Modern, symbolic, and postmodern perspectives,” Oxford: Oxford University Press
[41]  J. Herman and C. Hulin, “Studying organizational attitudes from individual and organizational frames of reference,” Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, vol.8, no.1, pp.84-108
[42]  G. Hirst, P. Budhwar, B. Cooper, M. West, C. Long, X. Chongyuan, and H. Shipton, “Cross-cultural variations in climate for autonomy, stress and organizational productivity relationships: A comparison of Chinese and UK manufacturing organizations,” Journal of International Business Studies, vol.39, no.8, pp.1343-1358, (2008)
[43]  J. Hoy, “Legal professions: Work, structure, and organization,” Contemporary Sociology, vol.32, no.6, pp.761, (2003)
[44]  W. K. Hoy, “An analysis of enabling and mindful school structures. Some theoretical, research and practical considerations,” Journal of Educational Administration, vol.41, no.1, pp.87-108, (2003)
[45]  W. Hoy and C. Miskel, “Educational administration: Theory, research, and practice,” NASSP Bulletin, vol.62, no.422, pp.115-116
[46]  W. K. Hoy and S. R. Sweetland, “Designing better schools: The meaning and nature of enabling school structure,” Educational Administration Quarterly, vol.37, no.3, pp.296-321, (2001)
[47]  C. Hulin and M. Blood, “Job enlargement, individual differences, and worker responses,” Psychological Bulletin, vol.69, no.1, pp.41-55
[48]  S. Ivarsson and B. Ekehammar, “Women’s entry into management: Comparing women managers and non‐managers,” Journal of Managerial Psychology, vol.16, no.4, pp.301-314, (2001)
[49]  S. M. Jex, “Organizational psychology: A scientist-practitioner approach,” New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., (2002)
[50]  J. Johari, K. Yahya, D. Mit, and A. Omar, “The dimensions of job characteristics: A validation study in a Malaysian context,” International Business Management, vol.5, no.2, pp.91-103, (2011)
[51]  P. Jorde-Bloom, “Closing the gap: An analysis of teacher and administrator perceptions of organizational climate in the early childhood setting,” Teaching and Teacher Education, vol.4, no.2, pp.111-120
[52]  T. A. Judge, J. E. Bono, and E. A. Locke, “Personality and job satisfaction: The mediating role of job characteristics, Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.85, no.2, pp.237-249, (2000)
[53]  R. M. Kanter, “Commitment and social organization: A study of commitment mechanisms in Utopian communities,” American Sociological Review, vol.33, no.4, pp.499-517
[54]  J. Koch and R. Steers, “Job attachment, satisfaction, and turnover among public sector employees, Journal of Vocational Behavior, no.12, no.1, pp.119-128
[55]  R. Krejcie and D. Morgan, ‘Determining sample size for research activities,” Educational and Psychological Measurement, vol.30, no.3, pp.607-610, 1970
[56]  L. Lim and F. Ling, “Human resource practices of contractors that lead to job satisfaction of professional staff,” Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, vol.19, no.1, pp.101-118, (2012)
[57]  C. Martin and N. Bennett, “The role of justice judgments in explaining the relationship between job satisfaction and organizational commitment,” Group & Organization Management, vol.21, no.1, pp.84-104
[58]  J. Mathieu and D. Zajac, “A review and meta-analysis of the antecedents, correlates, and consequences of organizational commitment,” Psychological Bulletin, vol.108, no.2, pp.171-194
[59]  A. A. Matubber and K. M. Miah, “A comparative study of job satisfaction of the Islamic bank and the conventional bank employees in Bangladesh,” Journal of Behavioural Sciences, vol.12, pp.19-32, (2001)
[60]  M. McShane, S. Nirenburg, and B. Jarrell, “Modeling decision-making biases,” Biologically Inspired Cognitive Architectures, vol.3, pp.39-50, (2013)
[61]  L. McGuigan and W. Hoy, “Principal leadership: Creating a culture of academic optimism to improve achievement for all students,” Leadership and Policy in Schools, vol.5, no.3, pp.203-229, (2006)
[62]  R. McGuigan, “Integral conflict analysis: A comprehensive quadrant analysis of an organizational conflict,” Conflict Resolution Quarterly, vol.22, no.3, pp.349-363, (2005)
[63]  I. Meadows, “Organic structure, satisfaction, and personality,” Human Relations, vol.33, no.6, pp.383-392
[64]  P. J. Meyer and J. N. Allen, “Commitment in the workplace: Theory, research, and application,” Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
[65]  H. Mintzberg, “Structure in fives: Designing effective organizations,” Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall
[66]  J. H. Morris and R. A. Snyder, “A second look at the need for achievement and need for autonomy as moderators of role perception-outcome relationships,” Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.64, no.2, pp.173-178
[67]  C. Mottaz, “Determinants of organizational commitment,” Human Relations, vol.41, no.6, pp.467-482
[68]  R. T. Mowday, L. M. Porter, and R. M. Steers, “Employee-organisational linkage,” New York: Academic Press
[69]  R. T. Mowday, R. M. Steers, and l. W. Porter, “The measurement of organizational commitment,” Journal of Applied Psychological Association, vol.74, pp.152-156
[70]  C. W. Mueller and S. -W. Kim, “The contented female worker: Still a paradox?” Hegtvedt, K.A. and Clay-Warner, J. (Ed.) Justice (Advances in Group Processes, Vol. 25), Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp.117-149, (2008), https://doi.org/10.1016/S0882-6145(08)25006-X(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[71]  D. Nelson and J. Quick, “The theory of preventive stress management: A 33-year review and evaluation,” Stress and Health, vol.27, no.3, pp.182-193, (2011)
[72]  G. Oldham and J. Hackman, “Relationships between organizational structure and employee reactions: Comparing alternative frameworks,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.26, no.1, pp.66-83
[73]  C. A. O'Reilly and D. F. Caldwell, “Informational influence as a determinant of perceived task characteristics and job satisfaction,” Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.64, no.2, pp.157-165
[74]  W. Ouchi, “The relationship between organizational structure and organizational control,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.22, no.1, pp.95
[75]  R. Payne and R. Mansfield, “Correlates of individual perceptions of organizational climate,” Journal of Occupational Psychology, vol.51, no.3, pp.209-218
[76]  L. W. Porter, “Job attitudes in management: Perceived deficiencies in need fulfillment as a function of job level,” Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.46. no.6, pp.375-384, https://doi.org/10.1037/h0047808(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[77]  L. Porter and E. Lawler, “Properties of organization structure in relation to job attitudes and job behavior, Psychological Bulletin, vol.64, no.1, pp.23-51
[78]  L. Porter and R. Steers, “Organizational commitment, job satisfaction, and turnover among psychiatric technicians,” Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.59, no.5, pp.603-609
[79]  J. Price and C. Mueller, “On the causal ordering of job satisfaction and organizational commitment,” Academy of Management Journal, vol.29, no.4, pp.847-858
[80]  D. Pugh, D. Hickson, C. Hinings, and C. Turner, “Dimensions of organization structure,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.13, no.1, pp.65-105
[81]  S. Ranson, B. Hinings, and R. Greenwood, “The structuring of organizational structures,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.25, no.1, pp.1-17
[82]  J. Rizzo, R. House, and S. Lirtzman, “Role conflict and ambiguity in complex organizations,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.15, no.2, pp.150-163
[83]  B. Rosen, “Family structure and achievement motivation,” American Sociological Review, vol.26, no.4, pp.574-585
[84]  D. Roy, R. Kahn, D. Wolfe, R. Quinn, J. Snoek, and R. Rosenthal, “Organizational stress: Studies in role conflict and ambiguity,” American Sociological Review, vol.30, no.4, pp.620
[85]  H. Sims, A. Szilagyi, and R. Keller, “The measurement of job characteristics,” Academy of Management Journal, vol.19, no.2, pp.195-212
[86]  P. E. Spector, “Job satisfaction: Application, assessment, causes and consequences,” California, Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications
[87]  G. Spreitzer, M. Kizilos, and S. Nason, “A dimensional analysis of the relationship between psychological empowerment and effectiveness satisfaction, and strain,” Journal of Management, vol.23, no.5, pp.679-704
[88]  R. Steers, “Problems in the measurement of organizational effectiveness,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.20, vo.4, pp.546-558,”
[89]  R. Steers, “Antecedents and outcomes of organizational commitment,” Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.22, no.1, pp.46-56
[90]  R. Steers, “Individual differences in participative decision-making,” Human Relations, vol.30, no.9, pp.837-847
[91]  R. Steers, and D. Braunstein, “A behaviorally-based measure of manifest needs in work settings,” Journal of Vocational Behavior, vol.9, no.2, pp.251-266
[92]  J. Stevens, J. Beyer, and H. Trice, “Assessing personal, role, and organizational predictors of managerial commitment,” Academy of Management Journal, vol.21, no.3, pp.380-396
[93]  T. Burns and G. Stalker, “The Management of innovation,” Tavistock, London, England
[94]  A. Turner and P. Lawrence, “Industrial jobs and the worker: An investigation of response to task attributes,” American Sociological Review, vol.30, no.5, pp.810
[95]  A. Van de Ven, “A framework for organization assessment,” Academy of Management Review, vol.1, no.1, pp.64-78
[96]  H. Welsch and H. LaVan, “Inter-relationships between organizational commitment and job characteristics, job satisfaction, professional behavior, and organizational climate,” Human Relations, vol.34, no.12, pp.1079-1089
[97]  S. Yung Chou and E. Lopez-Rodriguez, “An empirical examination of service-oriented organizational citizenship behavior,” Managing Service Quality: An International Journal, vol.23, no.6, pp.474-494, (2013)

CITATION

  • APA:
    Masnour,H.F.& David*,S.A.(2021). Teacher's Organizational Commitment in Mechanistic School Structures: A Study Conducted on the Job Characteristics of a Private School in Abu Dhabi. Asia-Pacific Journal of Educational Management Research, 6(1), 13-28. 10.21742/AJEMR.2021.6.1.02
  • Harvard:
    Masnour,H.F., David*,S.A.(2021). "Teacher's Organizational Commitment in Mechanistic School Structures: A Study Conducted on the Job Characteristics of a Private School in Abu Dhabi". Asia-Pacific Journal of Educational Management Research, 6(1), pp.13-28. doi:10.21742/AJEMR.2021.6.1.02
  • IEEE:
    [1] H.F.Masnour, S.A.David*, "Teacher's Organizational Commitment in Mechanistic School Structures: A Study Conducted on the Job Characteristics of a Private School in Abu Dhabi". Asia-Pacific Journal of Educational Management Research, vol.6, no.1, pp.13-28, Jun. 2021
  • MLA:
    Masnour Hadi Fouad and David* Solomon Arulraj. "Teacher's Organizational Commitment in Mechanistic School Structures: A Study Conducted on the Job Characteristics of a Private School in Abu Dhabi". Asia-Pacific Journal of Educational Management Research, vol.6, no.1, Jun. 2021, pp.13-28, doi:10.21742/AJEMR.2021.6.1.02

ISSUE INFO

  • Volume 6, No. 1, 2021
  • ISSN(p):2207-5380
  • ISSN(e):2207-290X
  • Published:Jun. 2021

DOWNLOAD