Health Care with Indigenous Women: Respectful Partnerships

AUTHORS

Joanne Whitty Rogers,St. Francis Xavier University, Rankin School of Nursing. Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada
Alex Marion,St. Francis Xavier University, Rankin School of Nursing. Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada
Cathy MacDonald,St. Francis Xavier University, Rankin School of Nursing. Antigonish, Nova Scotia, Canada

ABSTRACT

World cultures are comprised of two forms - individualist and collectivist. The dominant form of culture in western Europe and North America is the individualist form. However, most of the world's cultures, including Indigenous cultures, are collectivist, where loyalty to community and relationality outweighs individualism. In a shared world, we need dialogue between and among cultures if we are to achieve harmony and understanding. The health state of Canada's Indigenous people is considerably lower than that of non-Indigenous Canadians. Health inequities are associated with low income and lack of accessible and culturally safe health care. A complex web of socioeconomic, cultural, historical, and political factors affects health. Partnerships grounded in respect in working with Indigenous communities can begin to address health inequities. A Two-Eyed Seeing approach serves as a guide to respectful partnerships by bringing people with different ways of knowing together. Using illustrative stories and findings from our respective practice and research in Mi'kmaw and Inuit communities, and informed by the Truth and Reconciliation Committee of Canada report, this paper is a philosophical discussion of the importance of respectful and trustworthy relationships between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people.

 

KEYWORDS

Indigenous, Mi’kmaq women, Two-eyed seeing, nurses, Partnerships, Research, Practice

REFERENCES

[1] Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada [TRC], “Final report of the truth and reconciliation commission of Canada, volume one: Summary: Honoring the truth,” reconciling for the future, Toronto, ON: James Lorimer & Company, (2015)
[2] Indigenous Services Canada, “Preventing and managing chronic disease in First Nations communities: A guidance framework,” Retrieved from https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2018/aanc-inac/H34-313-1-2017- eng.pdf, (2018)
[3] R. Dyck, N. Osgood, T.H. Lin, A. Gao, and M.R. Stang, “Epidemiology of diabetes mellitus among first nations and non-first nations adults,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, vol.182, no.3, pp.249-256, (2010)
[4] C. Loppie Reading and F. Wein, “Health inequalities and social determinants of Aboriginal peoples’ health,” Retrieved from https://www.nccah-ccnsa.ca/docs/social%20determinates/nccah-loppie-wien_report.pdf, (2009)
[5] C. Loppie, “In determinants of indigenous people’s health: Beyond the social,” Edited M. Greenwood, S. D, Leeuw, N. M. Lindsay, Toronto, Canadian Scholars, pp 3-17, (2018)
[6] A. Hatcher, C. Bartlett, A. Marshall, and M. Marshall, “Two-eyed seeing in the classroom environment: concepts, approaches, and challenges,” Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics and Technology Education, vol.9, no.3, pp.141-153, (2009)
[7] P. Knudtson and D. Suzuki, “Wisdom of the elders. Toronto,” ON: Stoddart
[8] Government of Canada, “Crown decisions relations and Northern Affairs Canada,” Retrieved from: https://www.rcaanc-cirnac.gc.ca/eng/1100100013785/1529102490303, (2019)
[9] V.J. Kirkness and R. Barnhardt, “First nations and higher education: The four’s - respect, relevance, reciprocity, and responsibility,” Journal of American Indian Education, vol.30, no.3, pp.1-10
[10] P. Farmer, “To repair the world,” Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, (2013)
[11] World Health Organization [WHO], “WHO recommendation on respectful maternity care during labor and childbirth,” Retrieved from https://extranet.who.int/rhl/topics/preconception-pregnancy-childbirth-and-postpartum-care/care-during-childbirth/who-recommendation-respectful-maternity-care-during-labour-and-childbirth, (2018)
[12] F. Kolahdooz, K. Launier, F. Nader, K.J., Yi, P. Baker, T.L. McHugh, H. Vallianatos, and S. Sharma, “Canadian Indigenous women’s perspectives of maternal health and health care services: A systematic review,” Diversity and Equality in Health Care Services, vol.13, no.5, pp.334-348, (2016)
[13] M.A. Bohren, J.P., Vogel, J.P., E.C. Hunter, O. Lutsiv, S.K. Makh, J.P. Sousa, C. Aguiar, F.S., F.S Coneglian, A. Luiz, A. Diniz, O. Tuncalp, D. Javadi, O.T. Oladapo, R. Khosla, M.J. Hindin, and A.M. Gulmezoglu, “The mistreatment of women during childbirth in health facilities globally: A mixed-methods systematic review,” PLoS Medicine, vol.12, no.6, e1001847, (2015)
[14] F. Diaz-Tello, “Invisible wounds: Obstetric violence in the United States,” Reproductive Health Matters, vol.24, no.47, pp.56-64, (2015) DOI: 10.1016/j.rhm.2016.04.004(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[15] S. Hennig, “Shut up… and push! - Obstetrical violence, dignified health care, and the intersection with human Rights,” Retrieved from https://jis.athabascau.ca/index.php/jis/article/view/216/328, (2016)
[16] H. Goer, “Cruelty in maternity wards: Fifty years later,” Journal of Perinatal Education, vol.19, no.3, pp.33-42, (2010) DOI:10.1624?105812410X514413(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[17] A. Brown, C. Varcoe, and B. Calam, “The birthing experiences of rural aboriginal women in context: Implications for Nursing,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.43, no.4, pp.101-117, (2011)
[18] J. Whitty-Rogers, J., Etowa, and J., Evans, “Until Our hearts are on the ground: Aboriginal mothering, oppression, resistance and rebirth community in Nova Scotia,” Edited D.M. Lavel-Havard & J.C. Lavel (Ed.), Toronto, On: Demeter Press, (2006)
[19] J. Whitty-Rogers, V. Caine, and B. Cameron, “Aboriginal women’s experiences with gestational diabetes mellitus: A participatory study,” Advances in Nursing Science, vol.39, no.2, pp.181-198, (2016)
[20] R. Reed, R., Sharman, C. Inglis, “Women’s description of childbirth trauma relating to care provider actions and interactions,” BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, vol.17, no.1, pp.21, (2017)
[21] M. Sadler, M.J. Santos, D. Ruiz-Berdún, G.L. Rojas, E. Skoko, P. Gillen, and J.A. Clausen, “Moving beyond disrespect and abuse: addressing the structural dimensions of obstetric violence,” Reproductive Health Matters, vol.2, no.47, pp.47-55, (2016)
[22] C. MacDonald, R. Martin-Misener, A. Steenbeek, and A. Browne, “Honoring stories: Mi’kmaq women experiences with pap smear screening in eastern Canada,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.47, no.1, pp.72-96, (2015)
[23] A. J. Browne and A. J., “The meaning of respect: A First Nations perspective,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.27, no.4, pp.95-109, (1995)
[24] A.J. Browne and J. Fiske, “First nations women’s encounters with mainstream healthcare services,” Western Journal of Nursing Services, vol.23, no.2, pp.126-147, (2001)
[25] A.J. Browne, “Clinical encounters between nurses and First Nations women in a western Canadian hospital,” Social Science & Medicine, vol.64, pp.2165-2176, (2007)
[26] D. Gregory, D., and J. Harrowing, “Indigenous people’s health and health-care equity: Seven years later,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.44, no.2, pp.15-18, (2012)
[27] Canadian Nurses Association, “Code of ethics for registered nurses,” Retrieved from https://www.cna-aiic.ca/~/media/cna/page-content/pdf-en/code-of-ethics-2017-edition- secure- interactive, (2017)
[28] The National Aboriginal Council of Midwives, “What is an indigenous midwife?,” Retrieved from https://indigenousmidwifery.ca/indigenous-midwifery-in-canada
[29] A.J. Browne, C. Varcoe,. J. Lavoie, V. Smye, S.T. Wong, M. Krause, D. Tu, O. Goodwin, K. Khan, and A. Fridkin, “Enhancing health care equity with Indigenous populations: Evidenced-based strategies from an ethnographic study,” BioMed Central, vol.16, article no.544, (2016) DOI 10.1186/s12913-016-1707-9(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[30] A.J. Browne, “Discourses influencing nurses’ perceptions of first nations patients,” Canadian Journal Nursing Research, vol.37, no.4, pp.62-87, (2005)
[31] M.D. Stout, “Ascribed health and wellness, Atikowisi miýw-_ay_awin, to achieved health and wellness, Kaskitamasowin miýw-a_ay_awin: Shifting the paradigm,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.44, no.2, pp.11-14, (2012)
[32] S. Flicker and C.A. Worthington, “Public health research involving Aboriginal peoples: Research ethics board stakeholders’ reflections on ethics principles and research process,” Canadian Public Health Association, vol.101, no.1, pp.19-22, (2012)
[33] M. Iwama, M. Marshall, M. A. Marshall, and C. Bartlett, “Two-eyed seeing and the language of healing in community-based research,” Canadian Journal of Native Education, vol.32, no.2. pp.3-23, (2009)
[34] W. Warry, “Ending denial: Understanding Aboriginal issues,” Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press, (2007)
[35] R.T. Pastore, “The Beothuk,” Retrieved from https://www.heritage.nf.ca/aboriginal/beothuk.html, (1997)
[36] Aboriginal Healing Foundation, “Dancing, stinging, and speaking the healing story: Healing through creative arts,” https://www.ahf.ca/downloads/healing-through- creative-arts.pdf, (2012)
[37] Canadian Institute of Health Research, “CIHR guidelines for health research involving Aboriginal people,” Ottawa, On: Author, (2007)
[38] L. Knockwood, “Out of the depths: The experiences of Mi’kmaw children at the Indian residential school at Shubenacadie,” Blackpoint, NS, Canada: Fernwood Publishing, (2001)
[39] M. King, A. Smith, and M. Gracey, “Indigenous health part 2: The underlying causes of the health gap,” Lancet, vol.3, no.74, pp.76-84, (2009)
[40] United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, 2019 International year of Indigenous languages. Retrieve from https://www.un.org/development/desa/dspd/2019/01/2019-international-year-of- indigenous- languages, (2019)
[41] T. Sable. and B. Francis, “The language of this land, Mi’kma’ki,” Sydney, NS: Cape Breton University Press, (2012)
[42] O. McIvor, A. Napoleon, and K.M. Dickie, “Language and culture as protective factors for at-risk communities,” Journal of Aboriginal Health, pp.6-25, (2009)
[43] L.J. Kirmayer, S. Dandeneau, E. Marshall, M.K. Phillips, and K. Williamson, “Rethinking resilience from indigenous perspectives,” The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, vol.56, no.2, pp.84-91, (2011)
[44] V. Deloria, “Custer died for your sins,” New York: The Macmillan Co., (1969)
[45] E.J. Hedicare. Editor, “Applied anthropology in Canada: understanding Aboriginal issues,” 2nd Ed, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, (2008)
[46] I. Mosby, “Administering colonial science: Nutrition research and human biomedical experimentation in Aboriginal communities and residential schools, 1942-1952,” Histoire Sociale/Social History, vol.46, no.91, pp.145-172, (2013) DOI:10.1353éhis.2013.0015(CrossRef)(Google Scholar)
[47] M. Battiste, “Decolonizing education: Nourishing the learning spirit,” Vancouver, BC: UBC Press, (2013)
[48] C. Bourassa, J. McElhaney, and E. Olesen, “Cultural safety,” Retrieved from https://www.queensu.ca/sps/-sites/webpublish.queensu.ca.spswww/files/files/Events/Conferences/RCAP/Papers/Bourassa_RCAP_conceptsOct2016.pdf, (2016)
[49] D. Martin, “Two-Eyed Seeing: A framework for understanding Indigenous and non-Indigenous approaches to Indigenous health research,” Canadian Journal of Research, vol.42, no.2, pp.20-42, (2012)
[50] B. O’Brien, “Birth on the land: Memories of Inuit elders and traditional midwives,” Iqaluit, NU: Nunavut Arctic College, (2012)
[51] J.S. Savage, “Postmodern implications of modern childbirth,” International Journal of Childbirth Education, vol.17, no.4. pp.8-10, (2002)
[52] M. Battiste, “Introduction: Unfolding the lesions of Colonization, in Reclaiming indigenous voice and vision,” Editor M. Battiste, pp.xvi-xxx, Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, (2000)
[53] K. A. Van Herk, D. Smith, and D. A. Andrew, “Identity matter: Aboriginal mother’s experiences of accessing health care,” Contemporary Nurse, vol.37, no.1, pp.57-68, (2011)
[54] M. McDermott and F.L. Samson, “White racial and ethnic identity in the United States,” Annual Review of Sociology, vol.31, pp.245-261, (2005).
[55] E. A. McGibbon and J.B. Etowa, “Anti-racist healthcare practice,” Toronto, ON, Canada: Canadian Scholars’ Press, (2009)
[56] A.J. Browne, C.M. Varcoe, S.T. Wong, S. T., V.L. Smye, J. Lavoie, D. Littlejohn, and S. Lennox, “Closing the health equity gap: Evidence-based strategies for primary health care organizations,” International Journal for Equity in Health, vol.11, no.59, pp.1-15, (2012)
[57] Aboriginal Nurses Association of Canada (ANAC), “Framework for cultural competence and safety in Aboriginal health nursing living in dignity and truth,” Ottawa, ON, (2007)
[58] A.J. Browne, C. Varcoe, V. Smye, S. Reimer-Kirkham, M.J. Lynam, and S. Wong, “Culturally safety and the challenges of translating critically oriented knowledge in practice,” Nursing Philosophy, vol.10, pp.167-179, (2009)
[59] I. M. Ramsden, “Cultural safety and nursing education in Aotearoa and Te Waipounamu,” Unpublished master’s thesis, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand, (2002)
[60] D. Arieli, M. Mashiach, M.J. Hirschfeld, and V. Friedman, “Cultural safety and nursing education in divided societies,” Nursing Education Perspectives, vol.33, no.6, pp.364-368, (2012)
[61] D. Doutrich, K., Arcus, L. Dekker, J. Spuck, and C. Pollock-Robinson, “Cultural safety in New Zealand and the United States: looking at a way forward together,” Journal of Transcultural Nursing, vol.23, no.2, pp.143-150, (2012)
[62] B. J. Astle and S. Barton, “Culture and ethnicity in Canadian fundamentals of nursing (4th ed.),” Editor P. Potter, A. Perry A., K. C. Ross-Kerr., & M. Wood (Eds.), Toronto, ON, Canada: Mosby, pp.114-131, (2010)
[63] A.J. Browne and M.D. Stout, “Moving towards Nahi: Addressing health equity in research involving indigenous people,” CJNR, vol.44, no.2, pp.7-10, (2012)
[64] L.T. Smith, “Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous peoples,” New York: University of Otago Press
[65] L.T. Smith, “Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous peoples (2nd Ed.),” New York: Zed Books, (2012)
[66] C. Loppie, “Learning from the grandmothers: Incorporating Indigenous principles into qualitative research,” Qualitative Health Research, vol.17, no.2, pp.276-284, (2007)
[67] T. Harding, “Cultural safety: A vital element for nursing ethics,” Nursing Praxis in New Zealand, vol.27, no.1, pp.4-11, (2013)
[68] A. Marshall, “Two-eyed seeing: Science education for children and youth,” Retrieved from https://www.turtleisland.org/culture/twoeyed.htm, (2007)
[69] A. Vukic, D. Gregory, and R. Martin-Misener, “Indigenous health research: Theoretical and methodological perspectives,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.44, no.2, pp.146-161, (2012)
[70] W. Ermine, “The ethical space of engagement,” Indigenous Law Journal, vol.6, no.1, pp.193-203, (2007)
[71] Canadian Health Network, “Aboriginals peoples glossary,” Retrieved from https://www.canadian-health-network.ca/faq faq/aboriginal_peoples-autochtones/glossarye.html, (2000)
[72] M. Johnson, “The presence of Mother Earth in women’s ceremonies: Observations of a woman/Wiccan practitioner,” Canadian Woman Studies, vol.17, no.1, p.121
[73] M.K. Kholghi, G. Bartlett, M. Phillips, J. Salsberg, A.M. McComber, and A.C. Macaulay, “Evaluating an Indigenous health curriculum for diabetes prevention: Engaging the community through talking circles and knowledge translation of results,” Family Practice, vol.35, no.1, pp.80-87, (2017)
[74] H.J. Federoff, J.D. Gostin, “Evolving from reductionism to holism: Is there a role for systems medicine?,” Journal of the American Medical Association, vol.302, no.9, pp.994-996, (2009)
[75] E.C. Polifroni and M.L. Welch., “In perspectives on philosophy of science in nursing: an historical and contemporary anthology,” Edited E.C. Polifroni & M. L. Welch (Eds.), Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, pp.1-11, (1999)
[76] M. McFarland, “Nursing theorist’s and their work,” Edited A.M. Tomey & M.R. Alligood (Eds.), St. Louis Missouri: Mosby, Elsevier, pp.472-496, (2005)
[77] M.R. McFarland, “In Leininger’s Transcultural Nursing: Concepts, theories, research, and practice,” M.R. McFarland & H.B. Wehbe-Alamah (Eds), New York: McGraw-Hill, pp.39-56, (2018)
[78] S. Roach, “Caring, the human mode of being: A blueprint for the health professions,” Ottawa, ON: CHA Press, (2002)
[79] H.L. Erikson, “Philosophy and theory of holism,” Nursing Clinics of North America, vol.42, no.2, pp.139-163, (2007)
[80] R. R. Parse, “Witnessing as true presence,” Illuminations, vol.8, no.3, pp.1, (1999)
[81] P.L Chinn, “Peace and power: Active leadership for building community,” Boston, MA: Jones & Bartlett, (2008)
[82] T.J. Doucet, “Trusting another: A parse research method study,” Nursing Science Quarterly, vol.22, no.3, pp.259-266, (2009)
[83] B.L. Cameron, “The nursing “How are you”?” Phenomenology + Pedagogy, vol.10, pp.172-185, (1992)
[84] R. Naef, “Bearing witness: A moral way of engaging in the nurse-person relationship,” Nursing Philosophy, vol.7, no.3, pp.146-156, (2006)
[85] R.S. Dillon, “Respect and care: Toward moral integration,” Canadian Journal of Philosophy, vol.22, no.1, pp.105-132
[86] S. Gadow, “Relational narrative: The postmodern turn in nursing ethics,” Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice: An International Journal, vol.13, no.1, pp.57-70
[87] J. Whitty-Rogers, “Exploring Mi’kmaq women’s experiences with gestational diabetes mellitus,” Doctoral Dissertation, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, (2013)
[88] Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada, & Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans. Ottawa, ON: Government of Canada, (2014)
[89] J. Smylie, K. Bailey, E.L. Eason, Q, C. R. Grey, A. Archambault, M.M. Cummings, P. Lessard, C. Cuchie, W.J. Goldsmith, K.Seethram, H. Cohen, and Q.C. B.Downey, “SOGC policy statement: a guide for health professionals working with aboriginal peoples,” The sociocultural context of Aboriginal peoples in Canada, vol.22, no.12, pp.1070-1081, (2000)
[90] T.K. Young, “Review of research on Aboriginal populations in Canada: Relevance to their health needs,” British Medical Journal, vol.327, pp.419-422, (2003)
[91] S. Barton, “Discovering the literature on Aboriginal diabetes in Canada: A focus on holistic methodologies,” Canadian Journal of Nursing Research, vol.40, no.4, pp.26-54, (2008)
[92] M. Pidgeon and D.G. Hardy Cox, “Researching with Aboriginal peoples: Practices and principles,” Canadian, Journal of Native Education, vol.26, no.2, pp.96-106, (2002)
[93] C. MacDonald, “Using components of the medicine wheel for the development of a conceptual framework for understanding Aboriginal women in the context of Pap smear screening,” Pimatisiwin Journal: A Journal of Aboriginal and Indigenous Community Health, vol.6, no.3, pp.95-108, (2008)
[94] World Health Organization [WHO], “The prevention and elimination of disrespect and abuse during facility-based childbirth,” Retrieved from https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/134588/WHO_RHR_14.-23_eng.pdf, (2015)
[95] White Ribbon Alliance [WRA], “Respectful maternity care: The universal rights of childbearing women,” Retrieved from https://www.whiteribbonalliance.org/wpcontent/uploads/2017/11/Final_RMC_Charter.pdf, (2011)

CITATION

  • APA:
    Rogers,J.W.& Marion,A.& MacDonald,C.(2019). Health Care with Indigenous Women: Respectful Partnerships. International Journal of Advanced Nursing Education and Research, 4(3), 89-106. 10.21742/IJANER.2019.4.3.12
  • Harvard:
    Rogers,J.W., Marion,A., MacDonald,C.(2019). "Health Care with Indigenous Women: Respectful Partnerships". International Journal of Advanced Nursing Education and Research, 4(3), pp.89-106. doi:10.21742/IJANER.2019.4.3.12
  • IEEE:
    [1] J.W.Rogers, A.Marion, C.MacDonald, "Health Care with Indigenous Women: Respectful Partnerships". International Journal of Advanced Nursing Education and Research, vol.4, no.3, pp.89-106, Dec. 2019
  • MLA:
    Rogers Joanne Whitty, Marion Alex and MacDonald Cathy. "Health Care with Indigenous Women: Respectful Partnerships". International Journal of Advanced Nursing Education and Research, vol.4, no.3, Dec. 2019, pp.89-106, doi:10.21742/IJANER.2019.4.3.12

ISSUE INFO

  • Volume 4, No. 3, 2019
  • ISSN(p):2207-3981
  • ISSN(e):2207-3159
  • Published:Dec. 2019

DOWNLOAD